Compare

Squarespace vs Shopify for personalized products

Ask on the Squarespace forum how to charge for engraving or a gift box. The most common answer is “switch to Shopify”. Sometimes that’s right. Often it’s a big move to solve a small problem. Here’s an honest look at both sides.

Updated October 2026. We make OptionKit, a Squarespace plugin, so read this knowing that. We’ve tried to be fair to Shopify.

On this page

Why people say “switch to Shopify”

Shopify has an app store (a shop of add-ons you install on Shopify). Product options are one of its busiest categories. Apps such as Globo Product Options, Infinite Options, Easify and Hulk add checkboxes, text fields, swatches and dropdowns to a product page. They come with prices, conditional rules (options that show only when they apply) and file uploads. Their main paid tiers cost roughly $9 to $20 a month.

Squarespace has no app store of that kind. Its own tools stop at three things: (versions of a product, like “Large, Blue”), a plain add-to-cart form and four add-on products. So the advice has a point. On Shopify, this problem has been solved for years.

Squarespace vs Shopify: pricing and fees

  • A new site. Shopify is a different platform with different themes. Your pages, blog, galleries and layout are rebuilt, not moved. Products and customers can be exported and imported. Design can’t.
  • Your Squarespace work. Years of pages, custom CSS (code that changes how your site looks), the way your shop looks on a phone. Some of it transfers as ideas. None of it transfers as files.
  • Addresses and search rankings. Every page gets a new web address (URL). Done carefully, with redirects (a setting that sends visitors from an old page address to the new one), rankings mostly survive. Done quickly, they don’t.
  • Two bills instead of one. A Shopify plan plus the options app, plus whatever else you add from the app store.
  • Learning a new admin. The admin is where you run your shop. Orders, discounts, shipping, taxes and email are all in new places.
SquarespaceShopify
Cheapest plan that can sellBasic: $19 a month billed yearly, or $25 monthly. Squarespace adds a 2% fee on each sale.Basic: $29 a month billed yearly, or $39 monthly.
Cheapest plan with no extra fee on salesCore: $29 a month billed yearly, or $39 monthly.Basic, if you use Shopify Payments. Any other payment provider adds 2% on each sale.
Card fees on those plans2.9% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢
Paid product optionsOptionKit: $12 a month, or $120 a yearAn options app, about $9 to $20 a month

Prices in US dollars from squarespace.com/pricing and shopify.com/pricing, checked on 3 October 2026. They change, so check both before you decide.

On price alone, the two are close. The real cost of moving is the rebuild above.

Some shops have outgrown Squarespace in other ways too. For example:

  • wholesale (selling in bulk to other shops)
  • multiple locations
  • a large catalog (your list of products)
  • point of sale (selling in person with a card reader)

For those shops, the move can be worth it. For a shop that likes Squarespace and needs one thing, paid options, it rarely is.

Getting the options without moving

OptionKit adds the same kind of options to the Squarespace store you already have. Checkboxes, text, buttons, swatches, dropdowns and numbers, each with a price. Text priced by the letter. Options that show only when they apply.

It works inside Squarespace’s rules. Squarespace can only charge for products. So for each option that costs extra, you create a product for it, like “Engraving, $15”, on a page that isn’t in your menu. When a customer checks engraving and clicks Add To Cart, OptionKit puts that product in the cart too. Squarespace then charges for both, like any two products. What the customer typed shows on the order, next to a short code (like Item: KIWI-37) that matches it to the right item.

So your cart, checkout, orders, discounts and taxes stay exactly as they are. You build your options beside a preview. Then you paste your site code into (a box in Squarespace’s settings for code that runs on every page). That’s it.

Squarespace shopping cart with two walnut cutting boards. Each board’s engraving text, font, laser engraving and gift box charges are listed under it.
A real Squarespace cart with OptionKit (Clementine test store): each board’s engraving and gift box are listed under it, ready for checkout.

Side by side

Shopify + an options appSquarespace + OptionKit
Paid options on the product pageYesYes
Text priced by the letterMost appsYes
Options that show only when they applyMost appsYes
File upload from customersMost apps, on paid tiersYes. Files are kept on JuiceKit’s own storage with private links, and deleted 90 days after the item goes in the cart.
Live preview of text on the product photoSome apps, on higher tiersComing soon. Notify me at launch
Your current site, design and web addressesRebuiltUnchanged
Checkout and ordersShopify’sSquarespace’s, unchanged
SetupInstall the app, configure optionsPaste your site code, add your paid options to Squarespace, press Publish
Monthly cost for optionsAbout $9–$20 for the app$12 per store, free to build and test

When Shopify is the right answer

Maybe you need a visual preview on the product photo today. Shopify’s apps have it now. OptionKit doesn’t yet. Maybe you need point of sale in a shop, wholesale pricing, or a catalog in the thousands. Shopify’s platform is built for that in a way Squarespace isn’t. And if you were planning to redesign anyway, a platform move is a smaller extra step.

When staying is the right answer

If your store works, your customers find you, and the only thing missing is “check this box and pay $15”, stay. You don’t need a migration (moving to another platform). A plugin is an afternoon; a migration is a season.

Questions

Can Squarespace do product options at all?

Partly. It has variants, a form for collecting text, and up to four add-on products. None of them can put a price on a choice or a text field. A plugin fills that gap.

Is a plugin as reliable as a Shopify app?

A Squarespace plugin works within what Squarespace’s pages and cart allow. So it depends on Squarespace not changing those. OptionKit checks every item in the cart before checkout. If adding something to the cart only half works, OptionKit undoes it. It also updates itself, so you never install a new version. Test on your store before you sell, as you would with any app.

Can you use Shopify with Squarespace?

Yes, with Shopify’s Buy Button: code from Shopify that you paste into a Squarespace page. It means two systems, two bills and a checkout run by Shopify. If the only thing you want is product options, it’s more than you need. How to use Shopify with Squarespace covers how it works.